Equity

What is Equity?

The term “equity” refers to fairness and justice and is distinguished from equality: Whereas equality means providing the same to all, equity means recognizing that we do not all start from the same place and must acknowledge and make adjustments to imbalances. The process is ongoing, requiring us to identify and overcome intentional and unintentional barriers arising from bias or systemic structures.

Equity Vs Equality Illustration


NACE Research Supporting Equity in the Workplace

NACE Diversity Graduate Profile Reports

The NACE Diversity Graduate Profile Report provides diversity data for Class of 2021 college graduates based on academic major, institution, gender, race, and ethnicity, and median salary (where reported). Purchase one now and download it immediately.

JOIN A NATIONAL NETWORK OF ACTIVE PRACTITIONERS

Since 1956, NACE has served as the leading source of information on the employment of the college educated and forecasts hiring trends in the job market; identifies best practices and benchmarks; and tracks starting salaries, recruiting practices, and student outcomes.

Additionally, NACE provides extensive ways to connect with your peers via Affinity Groups, professional development opportunities, and an annual conference & expo. By joining NACE, you join an engaged, passionate community that's dedicated to strengthening the bridge from campus to career, and—through research, partnerships and knowledge-sharing—works to ensure equitable outcomes for all.

EXPLORE NACE MEMBERSHIPSEE OUR STRATEGIC PLANDOWNLOAD OUR DEI REPORT


Get the latest insights into building a diverse, inclusive, and equitable workforce

See how NACE and its members are advocating for equity and implementing it around the country.

Nontraditional-Aged College Students and Career Preparation

October 28, 2024 | By Mary Gatta

Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
An adult learner talks with a classmate.

TAGS: diversity and inclusion, nace insights, student attitudes, surveys, trends and predictions,

The perception of college students is stereotypically a student between 18 and 20 years old who lives on a residential campus and has enrolled in college to prepare them for the start of their career. However, the reality is that this image does not capture the breadth of college students. The Lumina Foundation estimates that one-third of college students are 25 years and older; in graduate programs, students often return to complete advanced degrees years after earning their undergraduate degrees. This year, NACE took a deeper dive into its 2024 Student Survey data to provide a snapshot of the experiences of students who are 25 years old and older in undergraduate and graduate degree programs.

Nontraditional-aged students, defined as those 25 years or older, made up 24% of our 2024 Student Survey sample (N=2530). They represented students across undergraduate and graduate programs. (See Figure 1.)  It is this sample of students that will be the focus of this article.

Figure 1: Nontraditional Students by Degree Program, Student Survey 2024

 NPercent
Associate 270 10.7%
Bachelor’s 904 35.8%
Master’s 944 37.4%
Doctorate 409 16.2%
Total 2527 100.1%*
*Total does not equal 100 due to rounding

What Resources Do Nontraditional-Aged Students Use in Their Career Search?

Nontraditional-aged students are less likely to visit the career center on campus than are traditional-aged students. In our survey, 38% of students 25 years and older visited the career center (either virtually or in person) as compared to 51% of students less than 25 years old. Of the nontraditional-aged students who did visit the career center, more than half of them (52%) sought help with their resume and/or cover letter, 37% went for general career advice, 34% searched out career exploration assistance; and 30% visited for help with their job search.

Similarly, nontraditional-aged students are less likely to attend career fairs than are traditional-aged students across degree programs. Twenty-nine percent of nontraditional-aged students attended a career fair in the past year as compared to almost half (49%) of traditional-aged students. Looking within nontraditional students, there was relatively even distribution across degree programs, with one-third of masters’ level students attending a career fair, and approximately one-quarter each of students earning an associate, bachelor’s, or doctorate degree.

Nontraditional-aged students also use a variety of resources in their job searches. Eighty percent reported using traditional job search websites, 67% used employer websites, and 43% used social media.

Nontraditional-aged students are more likely than traditional aged students to report that their institution prepared them well for the next step in their career. Sixty-one percent of nontraditional-aged students report that their institution prepared them very or extremely well, as compared to 54% of traditional-aged students.

How Prevalent Are Experiential Learning Opportunities for Nontraditional-Aged Students?

While close to half of nontraditional-aged students (48%) reported that they participated in some form of experiential learning, this share is far lower than the 61% of traditional-aged students. Furthermore, nontraditional-aged students (54%) were less likely than traditional-aged students (64%) to be paid for their experiential learning. Looking across degree programs, graduate students are more likely to participate in experiential learning opportunities, while associate degree level students have the lowest participation rate. (See Figure 2.)

Figure 2: Experiential Learning by Degree Type for Nontraditional-Aged Students (N=2526)

Degree Participated in Experiential Learning Did Not Participate in Experiential Learning
Associate degree students 31.9% 69.9%
Bachelor’s degree students 39.0% 61.0%
Master’s degree students 52.3% 47.7%
Doctorate degree students 67.5% 32.5%

Regarding type of experiential learning, internships, practicum, and on-campus student work dominate the opportunities in which students participate. Experiential learning has strong benefits for nontraditional-aged students. Among those students who participated in an experiential learning opportunity, 78% felt that experiential learning helped them determine whether a field still interested them for a career, and three-quarters reported that they wanted a career in the industry after the experiential learning opportunity. Not surprisingly then, the vast majority (88%) said that the work that they did was meaningful. Furthermore, 85% reported that the work experience taught them several things that they never would have been able to learn in the classroom.  

What Are Nontraditional-Aged Students Looking for in Careers?

Nontraditional-aged students value flexibility in work modality. Almost half (47%) would prefer a hybrid work modality, 39% prefer to work fully in person, and 14% indicated a desire to work in a fully remote modality. In comparison, traditional-aged students are more likely to prefer fully in-person work over the other modalities. Fifty-six percent of traditional-aged students prefer fully in-person work, while 40% of them prefer hybrid and just 5% are looking for fully remote work.

In regard to job attributes, 80% of students report they look for job stability, 79% look for an organization that promotes healthy workplace culture, and 74% report that an organization that has a good insurance/benefits package is important. Looking specifically at benefits, 84% of students report that annual salary increases are very or extremely important, 75% report the importance of employer-paid medical insurance, and 71% strongly value the availability of dental insurance.

This article provides an overview of some key aspects of nontraditional-aged students’ experiences in college as they prepare for the next steps in their career. While some of their experiences mirror those of their traditional-aged peers, there are important areas where they diverge. This information can help career service professionals and recruiters better serve this growing group of college students.

Mary Gatta, Ph.D., is the director of research and public policy for NACE. Dr. Gatta has more than 20 years of teaching, research, and advocacy experience at colleges and in nonprofit organizations where she worked on issues of career education and workforce development.

Dr. Gatta’s work is centered on evidence-based research analysis to develop new solutions to current problems—particularly around economic security, education, and workforce policies. In all her research projects, she uses an equity and intersectionality lens.

Prior to joining NACE, Dr. Gatta served as an associate professor of sociology at City University of New York-Guttman and faculty director of the Ethnographies of Work program. In addition, she was the research director at the Rutgers University Center for Women and Work and a senior scholar at Wider Opportunities for Women in Washington D.C. Dr. Gatta also served on New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy's Labor and Workforce Development Transition Team.

Dr. Gatta received her bachelor’s degree in social science from Providence College and her master’s and Ph.D. in sociology from Rutgers University.

She can be reached at mgatta@naceweb.org.