From the Principles for Professional Practice Committee
As the job market for college graduates becomes more intense, employers and career centers alike ask questions about deadlines for job offer acceptance—particularly when deadlines come very early in the recruiting season. The timing of these offers and acceptances is a market-driven issue, with different industries experiencing varying degrees of urgency to fill positions. The role of NACE is not to enforce a specific time frame, but rather to encourage practices reasonable and appropriate for both employers and students, recognizing that ultimately the employment decisions are between the student and employer. Communication is key to these decisions, with regular contact between the employer and student vital from the point of offer to the start date.
In a robust and fast-paced job market for graduates and interns, some employers attempt to mitigate the effects of job-market competition with practices, including providing giveaways to students between the offer and the decision; providing financial incentives for accepting an offer; or requiring students to accept job offers within a short time frame. In some instances, students accept offers, continue their job searches, and renege on their accepted job offers if they find “better deals.”
Experience shows the best employment decisions for both students and employers are those that are made without pressure and with the greatest amount of information. Students given sufficient time to attend career fairs, participate in on-campus interviews, and/or complete the interviewing in which they are currently engaged are more likely to make good long-term employment decisions and may be less likely to renege on job acceptances.
Employers can use offer deadlines to assist in planning a recruitment strategy. The offer deadlines are influenced by the available candidate pool, the available recruitment opportunities, and anticipated staffing needs. Definitions of sufficient time for these offer deadlines vary, given industry standards, students’ prior experience with the employer, offer timing, quality of student, and proximity to graduation date/start time. Some issues that employers may wish to consider when establishing their offer deadlines are:
To further illustrate deadline issues, consider these scenarios and how time frames can be interpreted differently.
The NACE Principles Committee examined the issue based on NACE research, thoughts expressed by both career center and employer members, and discussion at the NACE 2008 Annual Conference. The primary basis for deliberation was the preamble to the Principles for Professional Practice document that directs members to:
The committee's opinion also drew upon several specific principles from the Principles document, including:
The NACE Principles for Professional Practice Committee understands that not all employers recruit at the same time of the year, nor do all colleges follow the same academic calendar. Therefore, recommending specific calendar dates for offers and acceptances would not be appropriate. Furthermore, many employers issue offers to their graduating co-ops or interns at the start of the employer’s recruiting cycle in order to provide those students priority consideration prior to extending offers to other students. Finally, shorter decision time frames would be appropriate if the candidate's graduation date and start date are very close.
Employers should assess their use of offer deadlines to ensure they are not placing undue pressure on a student. Pressure can come not only from the deadline, but also the use of financial incentives (signing bonuses, increased salary, and so forth) encouraging very early acceptance of offers. Today’s technology can significantly shorten the time from interview to receipt of complete job offer information. Although both students and employers benefit through this quick communication, it also can shorten the time available for students to make good decisions and increases the sense of urgency.
Career centers should provide guidance to students to help them make informed decisions when accepting or not accepting job offers. Career centers may provide guidance to employers and recommend that they consider extending deadlines when needed. Students should also be sensitive to employer needs and accept offers in a reasonable time. Career centers can help students work with employers to determine what might be a reasonable time.
NACE and the Principles Committee do not advocate enforcing a specific time frame, but rather encourage practices reasonable and appropriate for both employers and students. The Principles Committee believes that providing sufficient time for students to evaluate the employment opportunities offered to them allows them to make the wisest decisions for all concerned, creating a positive experience for candidates and employers, and ultimately reducing renege and attrition rates.
(Created 2008. Current as of June 2012.)
JobplaceNACE Blog: http://blog.naceweb.org/
NACE's Tweets: @NACE.org
Contact NACE StaffNACE's Newsletter: Spotlight
©2015 National Association of Colleges and Employers. All rights reserved.